7 May 2009

No three-strikes out – EU Parliament rejects Sarkozy’s plan

Berkman strikephoto © 2006 Michael Glasgow | more info (via: Wylio)

Do you rememeber Mr Sarkozy’s “three-strikes and you are out plan to fight file-sharers?

The intention of the french presidency was to use the reform of the EU telecommunications regulatory framework to insert provisions restricting the internet access of users engaged in copyright infringement. The plan aimed to primarily fight the use of P2P file-sharing platforms. Fortunately for file-sharers, because the plan is unlikely to be realized as the EU Parliament amended an informal agreement previously reached with the EU Council.

I personally have an understanding for the entertainment industry’s attepmts to achieve protection for its content in the digital era. It is also true that the internet constitutes an obstacle regarding the detection of and the law enforcemenet against copyright infringers. The internet service providers thus appear to be the convinient victim as they can barely run and/or hide.

On the other hand the entertainment industry must acknowledge that many users, due to several reasons, are more than limited in their efforts to lawfully access content. The infinging one remains then the only possibility they have in today’s entertainment coined society. That is why these users neither understand nor support the measures undertaken by the industry.

In my view, the industry should reconsider its current business models for content dissemination and attept to create new ones. This could be the path leading to reconcilliation with the users, not the “three-strikes” model.

Comments (3)

  1. 3 February 2010

    […] technology”. In regards to the latter, ACTA is feared by many to bring the so called “three strikes and you are out” rule that would practically lead to an internet denial for, say, users of infringing file sharing […]

  2. 19 April 2011

    […] technology”. In regards to the latter, ACTA is feared by many to bring the so called “three strikes and you are out” rule that would eventually lead to an internet denial for, say, users of infringing file sharing […]

  3. 26 May 2011

    […] the country which advertised the three strikes rule on a large scale and did eventually adopt it, has also a watchdog. A dog to watch for file-sharing […]

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge